First threesome experience

My girlfriend’s birthday was back in February, around the same week of Valentine’s Day. She’s never been adventurous in the bedroom, but for years had mentioned that she always wanted to do a MFM three way. She said she loved the idea of two men on their knees, worshiping her. I had never done that before, and like a lot of guys, was pretty anxious about having another man be with my girl. But since she brought it up several times, I decided we would try it as a combined Valentine’s/Birthday gift for her. I still haven’t stopped thinking about how it went.

We met the guy in person once before doing it. We had found him on our city’s R4R and he said he had a lot of experience with MFM three ways so we thought he’d be perfect. When we got to the hotel room with him, my girl started to undress first, and then I followed. Even though I’ve seen her naked a hundred times, I still got rock hard immediately like it was the first time. After scoping us out, Jordan (not his real named) started to undress himself and when we saw his cock, my girlfriend and I’s jaws were on the floor. We didnt do anything weird like pull out a ruler, but he had to be in the 8.5” ballpark. Biggest dick either of us had seen in person. I still cant believe this happened, but when I caught sight of his dick, my once-rock hard dick went completely flaccid on me. I’ve never had any issues with ED, so this in and of itself was a shock. My girl later joked that my penis was intimidated by seeing such a large member it retreated. Or maybe it was just a response to emasculation. While I cant speak for my girl, but I wasnt even impressed in a sexual way. It was like I was looking at the Grand Canyon. I never understood the hype for BBC until that day. From the minute he whipped that dick out, he completely owned the room.

The craziest thing about the whole situation was the contrasts to me and the guy. Not just in the dick size department, though I am about 4.5” long, but in everything else. I’m 5 foot six and a half inches tall whereas he was closer to 6’3-4” tall. I’m white and he is black. I have head hair but no facial hair, whereas he was bald with a thick beard and mustache. He was a former college football player but was still really muscular whereas I’m just not. Even the way our dicks pointed was different. His dick hung down to the floor whereas mine pointed upwards to my face when erect.

Our plan going into the threesome was for her to start by sucking my dick then move onto his. The hope was that by starting with me we would cement that this is still our relationship and he’s just a guess. But because i went completely soft upon seeing Jordan’s dick, my girl sucked him off first. This was the first time I’ve ever seen my girl try to deepthroat a dick and fail. She made it barely 2/3 of the way before gagging. Mercifully, I got hard again and was able get my turn of getting head. I almost nutted quickly, but was able to survive because she didnt spend as much time on mine because she was eager to move onto the full PIV sex. Again contradicting our plans going into the threesome, she told Jordan to enter her first. That was when the sparks really started flying. I’m proud to say I’ve made my girlfriend orgasm before, but only by giving her head. She had told me that she had never cum from penetration before, but after seeing her face and hearing her moans while Jordan did his thing, now I’m honestly not sure. After about 5-10 minutes, she then taps me in to go. I really wished she hadnt made me go second, because afterwards when I got my turn, she was looser than I had ever felt before. The deafening sound of her money and his skin slapping against hers was now replaced by her just breathing heavily as I slowly try to pump without busting. Unfortunately, I failed after about three minutes and blew right there in her pussy. She asked me to go to the bathroom to grab her some towels. I came back five seconds later with the bathroom towels and saw Jordan setting up behind my girlfriend. I was confused because it looked like he was going to do it in doggy style, but he had one hand across her chest. Then, I watched in amazement as he picked up my girlfriend and started railing her while holding her. This was a pretty huge feat, because my girlfriend is a bit on the bigger side of 5’9” 199lbs. So I didnt hav ethe strength to hold her like that, let alone the length to reach her pussy while moving in and out like that I didnt know what to do with the towels so I threw them on the bed and started tugging desperately on my once-again flaccid penis, trying to get it to come back to life. Unfortunately, by the time it got hard again, both Jordan and my girlfriend were exhausted and satisfied.

That was the only time we’ve done it, as we agreed upon it as a one time thing beforehand. But I still think of it all the time because I feel now like my girlfriend is a new woman now that she’s gotten to try a huge cock now. I’ve tried to emulate the energy and confidence that Jordan had, but it’s tough because that confidence definitely came partly from having a huge dick. I’m both hoping and dreading that she wants another threesome…