Strange Sympathy: Chapter 11 - Lauren and Dave's First Time

*Author's Note: It's been around 7 months since I posted a new chapter of this series. This is a long one as I unintentionally left this in such an odd spot and a lot of loose ends need to be tied up before we move on so the first half is a bunch of little snippets to do just that. If you want to skip the story building and get to the action then scroll down to the part marked "Friday Night".*

*Here is a bit of a refresher if you need one, this is not a full series recap, just what you need to know to provide some context for this chapter if you don't remember anything:
>!Dave and Lauren are neighbors and have an arrangement where if he gets kicked in the balls, Lauren will take care of him and try to make him feel better by making him cum. On Tuesday evening, Dave's ex wife, Candice payed him a visit. He said something she didn't like and she kneed him in the balls three times. Lauren came to look after him and spent the night there but he was in too much pain to get off. The next day Candice bragged about what she did in a group chat. Their daughter Daphne saw and visited Dave to check on him. Later that day Lauren visited Dave and he got off by groping and objectifying her but he couldn't get hard.!<*

If you want to start from the beginning:
https://www.reddit.com/r/BallbustingStories/comments/189tkkp/strange_sympathy_introduction_laurens_fantasy/

Wednesday Evening:

Daphne arrived at Candice's house to pick up her daughter Emma. Candice knew of a daycare that gave a special rate to teachers if they picked their kids up before 4 pm. Since Candice was a teacher, she convinced Daphne to bring Emma there and offered to pick Emma up before 4 pm each day so they could spend some quality time together before Daphne picked her up. The monthly savings were significant so Daphne agreed. Even though Daphne had taken the day off to visit Dave, she had stuck to her normal daycare routine because she didn't want to tip Candice off that she had taken the day off to see her dad.

When Daphne arrived, Candice had asked her if Dave had called her like he said he would. Daphne could tell she was trying to look for a reason to call him and make things difficult. She confirmed that Dave had called her. Candice mentioned how calm he seemed on the phone when she had talked to him, which was unusual. Daphne told her he was in a good mood when she saw him too.

Candice could sense there was something Daphne wasn't telling her. "I wonder if he's seeing someone new, he always was a bit more confident whenever he had a new girlfriend..."

Daphne was terrible at hiding things from her mom. Candice could tell right away that she was on to something. She tried to get it out of her but Daphne wouldn't budge. Candice threatened to pull her assistance with childcare if Daphne didn't spill.

Daphne regretted ever agreeing to this childcare arrangement. As soon as she agreed to it, Candice used it as leverage every chance she got.

Daphne reluctantly admitted that Dave had mentioned something about spending time with someone new but stopped short of mentioning who it was. She didn't like the look in Candice's eyes. Then she insisted that she had to go and catch her bus.

---

Lauren's face cracked into a huge smile. She was somewhat relieved that she was able to make Dave cum even if she couldn't get him hard. She looked down and readjusted her bra. She took a moment to examine her skin. It was red, sensitive and starting to welt and itch. She decided she should leave soon and take care of that.

It was only then that Dave noticed the red hand prints he had left on her skin. He was taken aback at the sight. He had no idea he had been that rough with her.

Lauren looked up at Dave and noticed the concern on his face. She looked at him confused, "What?" she asked, smiling. She was amused at the way he was looking at her. He looked so cute and concerned. She thought he was so sweet for caring about her like that.

"Lauren, are you okay? Was I too rough Sweetie?"

Lauren looked at him adoringly as she felt her skin stinging under her bra. She couldn't wait to get home and take it off. She gave a little nod yes and said "I should go home." She pulled her shirt over her head and headed to the washroom to wash her hands.

What did that mean? Yes, she was okay or yes he was too rough? Dave's testicles ached as he got dressed and hurried after her. He met her in the hallway and put his hand on her arm. "Hold on Sweetums..." Dave trailed off when he saw the look on Lauren's face go from loving to annoyed and she visibly cringed. He felt a wave of frustration, "Lauren if I crossed the line, I want you to let me know. Please don't leave angry." He glared into her eyes, searching for the truth.

Lauren liked seeing this side of him - firm but loving. Her facial expression relaxed. She shook her head and said "I'm not angry Dave but... could you not call me that?"

Dave looked at her confused. "I'm sorry Lauren what did I say to upset you?"

Lauren hesitated and brought her hand up to her forehead, covering her face, her eyes darted from side to side. She lowered her head and hunched her shoulders as she shuddered, "Please *don't* make me say it."

Dave thought back... what could it be... "Sweetums..?" Lauren twitched in annoyance. "Is that it? Sweetums? What's wrong with Sweetums?" he teased.

Lauren flinched each time he said it as if hearing the word caused her physical pain. "I just don't like it okay?!" she shrieked in aggravation.

"Okay Lauren, I'm sorry. I only meant it as a term of endearment." Dave reached over and flicked the hallway light on. He gently brushed her hair behind her shoulders and inspected the welts on her skin that were visible under her low cut shirt. He started to feel the worry rising in his chest as he noticed some bruising slightly discoloring the skin. "Lauren, I'm so sorry " He said as he lightly stroked the back of his fingers over one of the bruises, he could feel how hot the skin was. He couldn't understand how she seemed to not be bothered by the way he had physically hurt her but she flipped out when he called her a pet name. Why didn't she tell him he was hurting her?

Lauren started to get annoyed at his touch, it was starting to tickle and itch.

Dave inhaled deeply and blew across her warm skin, it always made him feel better when Lauren did it to him.

The breeze moved her hair and it tickled against her skin. She scooted to the side, away from Dave and covered her chest with her hands.

Dave felt like he kept messing things up.

Lauren looked at Dave's face and saw how hurt and concerned he was. She grabbed his hands and held them. "It's OK Dave, it's just all of this light touching is driving me crazy and not in a good way. I need to get going."

Dave hugged her gently before she left. "Are we okay?" He asked.

"We're OK," Lauren reassured him and put her hand on his shoulder. "Are you OK?"

"I'm fine" Dave said with a smile.

Lauren reached down and gently cupped his balls. Dave's posture stiffened as he felt pain from the light pressure of her hand pressing on his aching nuts. "Are these okay?"

Dave looked at her sadly and shook his head "No, but they will be."

"Would you like me to come over and check on them tomorrow?" she asked, looking up into his eyes.

Dave shook his head. "I'd love that but I'm going to have to work late and then I made plans to visit Daphne after she gets home with my granddaughter."

"Alright then, I guess I'll see you soon. Let me know when you'd like me to come over and... you know." She shrugged and turned to leave.

Dave watched Lauren as she walked towards the front door. He was completely baffled by what had just happened. *You know... What the hell does that mean?!* He thought to himself, confused. He wished she'd be more specific. He wanted to ask what she meant but he was too scared. He kept messing things up and he didn't want to annoy her again. She currently seemed open to the thought of seeing him again so he decided to consider that a win.


---

Lauren went home and took care of herself. She thought about Dave.

Dave was turning out to be a much bigger project than she'd imagined. She was wary of how emotionally attached they were getting. She remembered when Dave was touching her and grinning at her during the phone call with Candice. There was something about that moment that felt kind of sneaky and playful, like they were doing something they weren't supposed to do and only they knew about it. There was a closeness she felt... and she liked it. She thought about what Dave said *"everything feels right when we're together."* She didn't know how she felt about that. A part of her agreed but that was quite a statement to say out loud. She didn't know exactly what he meant by telling her that. She hoped Dave wasn't getting too attached. The only reason why they had been spending so much time together was because he kept getting his testicles hurt. In other words, they weren't a couple.

---

Later that night, she was looking at her social media and saw a post in a local dating group. It had a picture of Dave and the description said "I just found out my loser ex has a new girlfriend. Run girl!" It was posted by someone named Candi Add. In the comments someone had asked for more details and Candice complained about his size. Lauren rolled her eyes. Someone told her that wasn't a valid reason to post someone in the group.

Candice responded that she was just trying to warn the ladies in the group not to waste their time because he was probably sterile and impotent after the amount of abuse his balls had taken over the years. Two other women named Crystal and Jenny started to chime in and back her up, talking about how many times they'd seen her do it and even speaking of times they had participated. Lauren was appalled as she read the disgusting things they were saying. Some of the other members were chastising them and Lauren was grateful for that. Lauren wished she could blast them all with some choice words but she didn't want to make herself known to them and get blocked. She had work to do.

Lauren started documenting the post with screen shots and bookmarked the profiles of the three women so she could find them again in case the post got deleted. She spent a long while looking at their profiles and trying to find more information about them online. She hated them all.

---

Thursday Night:

Lauren was in her living room browsing the internet on her phone. She could hear a car approaching. She looked outside wondering if it was Dave arriving home and was aghast to see a white hatchback making it's way down the street. It slowed down and almost stopped in front of Dave's house. Lauren was certain that was Candice's car. What was she doing here?

The car slowly rolled by and then picked up speed as it passed by Lauren's driveway. Lauren's heart pounded. She stayed there on her couch, terrified that Candice was looking to confront Dave again. Why couldn't she just leave him alone?

She found herself waiting up for him to get home. She felt relived when she saw his car pull into his driveway around 20 minutes later.

---

Dave sat alone in his living room after he got home. He was unsure if how he had acted with Lauren was OK. He had been pretty controlling and was concerned that he may have put Lauren off. He was bemused by her behavior. She didn't seem bothered by the rough way he had treated her, but when he touched her lightly it was like she was being tortured.

She was so confusing to him. Why was she so nice and caring to him when he was in pain but so irritable when he showed concern for her? Her defenses were up, he wished she'd let him in. He wished she'd just let him love her.

He really wanted to see her that moment but he thought it would be wise to get a good rest and instead give himself something to look forward to. He sent her a text inviting her over for Friday night and she accepted.

---

Friday Night:

Lauren made her way to Dave's house. She was a little nervous to face him after what Candice had posted about him the night before.

Dave let Lauren in and was taken aback by the way she looked at him when they first made eye contact.

*Poor Dave... Hopefully I can make him feel better tonight.* She thought to herself as she sadly looked at him.

"Is everything okay Lauren?" He asked.

She nodded and stepped close to him. He hugged her and she slid her hand between his legs. She gently cupped his testicles, thinking about the amount of pain they'd been through.

They made their way to the bedroom and Lauren undressed Dave. Her heart sank when she saw that his testicles were still a bit bruised and swollen.

"Aw, your poor balls..." she said as she grabbed for them. "How much does this hurt?" she said as she lightly squeezed his testicles together.

"Oof" said Dave.

*That groan... take me now,* she thought to herself as she felt her desire searing through her. "Poor guy, let's see if we can get you feeling better." She said as she grabbed onto his soft cock and tried to coax an erection out of him.

Dave laid there helplessly as he watched this beautiful woman struggle to get his cock to wake up. This was such a weird situation to be in. A guy like him having a girl like her but only if his balls were in pain. He had wished for her for so long. Since the day she moved in, he had fantasized about having sex with her. "Be careful what you wish for..." he thought to himself.

"If I can't get this thing up, you might need to go to the hospital to get your balls examined by a professional, I think your bitchy ex wife might have broken your balls." Lauren said half out of frustration, half out of concern.

"I hope it doesn't come to that," Dave said, worried.

"What can I do to help?"

"Lay on your back and let me play with your tits" Dave requested.

She took off her shirt and bra. Dave's jaw dropped as he saw her perfect tits bouncing freely for the first time, they were more beautiful than he ever imagined. He was relived to see that the marks from Wednesday were gone.

She laid on her back but kept one hand wrapped around his cock. He laid on his side and used his left hand to squeeze her right boob. He grabbed the right side of her face and turned it so she was facing him and kissed her deeply on the lips while he groped her breasts. His cock stayed soft, he noticed that she wasn't really kissing him back. Maybe she was just a bad kisser? He doubted it. He slid his hand down the front of her panties and between her pussy lips and was surprised to find out how wet she was. Why was this woman so turned on by playing with his useless, soft penis?

Lauren felt so sorry for Dave and it was really turning her on. She looked down at his pathetic dick and wished there was something she could do for him. Every time she saw a guy get devastated by a kick to the nuts, she'd fantasize about "making it all better" for him. She wanted so badly to comfort the guy and take his mind off the pain, so much so that it had turned into a fetish for her.

She had been alarmed when she discovered that in some cases watching or even just thinking about a man getting hit in the balls turned her on. How could she judge others for finding that kind of pain funny when she found it arousing? She felt a lot of guilt and shame about it for a long time until she realized that it wasn't the pain that turned her on. Feeling sorry for men when they got hurt there was what turned her on.

There were three main criteria for a ballbusting scenario to be arousing for her:

- It was better if it was believable and not too extreme. Hospital visits weren't sexy to her and it was kind of hard to envision a guy getting ruptured and then "making it all better for him" - she wasn't a doctor.
- It was better if the guy didn't deserve or want it to happen because then her sympathy would kick in.
- Humiliation was a bonus because it would make her pity the man more.

In addition, she enjoyed lightly busting men when she was in bed with them, just to watch them squirm or hear the little moans they would make because it was arousing to her. However, the thought of flooring a man or hearing him cry in agony from her actions would ruin the mood for her.

She thought about Dave and how he was pressing all of her sympathy buttons right now...

Dave did not deserve the pain he was in and she felt like she would do anything to make Dave feel better, and by feel better, she meant get him hard and make him cum. If she could do that, she thought his balls would be OK. She hoped he wouldn't kiss her again though.

She laid there holding his dick and let him play with her pussy as his clumsy fingers felt around her wet slit. He really didn't know what he was doing down there, she thought to herself, but that was fine, she wasn't concerned about herself getting off.

She let go of his penis and sat up. She rolled him onto his back and leaned over him. She grabbed his cock and put it in her mouth, hoping it would make him hard.

Dave laid there in silent distress. How could he not be getting hard right now? He'd been dreaming of this moment for 8 months. His dream girl with his cock in her mouth.

"Do you wanna fuck me?" she asked desperately. Dave couldn't believe his ears, did she really just offer to have sex with him if he could get his dick to work?

"Yes!" he cried back, desperately hoping his dick would cooperate. He couldn't even think about the pain in his balls at the moment, he was so astonished by the scene unfolding in front of his very eyes as Lauren pulled off her underwear and said:

"OK but you've gotta get hard for me OK Baby, then I'll let you fuck me however you want"

"Please, let me go down on you" Dave pleaded. "I need to taste your cunt."

"If you think it will help..." Lauren replied. She laid on the bed with her legs spread. Dave got between her legs and started to lick.

"He isn't very good at this either" Lauren thought to herself, but she wasn't very surprised or disappointed.

Dave smelled the intoxicating scent of her womanhood while he slurped the juices out of her pussy. He fucked her pussy with his tongue and imagined how wonderful it would feel to fuck her pussy with his cock. She tasted so fresh and sweet. It had been so long since he'd eaten a woman out and he had forgotten how much he enjoyed it. He hoped she would let him do this again. He hoped she'd give him a rain check if he couldn't get his penis to work for her today, he didn't want to miss out on his chance to fuck her.

He hated his ex wife for doing this to his balls. On the other hand, if she hadn't done it then what would have happened this week? He probably wouldn't have gotten to spend all of this quality time with Lauren. He wouldn't have experienced her caring for him like she had the other night. Her just being there to comfort him meant so much to him, being able to fall asleep next to her, sharing his bed, waking up next to her. He probably wouldn't be where he is right now, on his bed with his dream girl spread out in front of him, practically begging him to get a hardon so he could fuck her with it. He yearned to feel what it was like to be inside of her. He needed it.

Lauren got bored of Dave licking her pussy. She knew she wasn't going to cum. She wished his penis would work so that she could just fuck him and go home. She didn't even really want to fuck him but she didn't want to leave without getting him off, that was her whole goal in coming over and she would do almost anything to make it happen.

"Dave, why don't you come back here and lay down?" Lauren said.

Dave stood up and to his surprise his penis had started to stiffen. He grabbed it in his hand and stroked it a few times. "Lookie what we have here haha!" Dave said, delighted. *Her pussy is magic* he thought to himself.

"Oh good job, I am so relieved that it's working again!" Lauren said. "OK, so how do you want to do this?"

"Girl on top." Dave said as he laid on the bed and got comfortable.

"OK, but let me suck you off a little so I can get you really hard OK?"

Lauren knelt over and put Dave's cock in her mouth again. She could feel Dave getting really hard.

It wasn't long before Dave asked, "Can we have sex now?". He was getting close and didn't want to blow his load in her mouth and miss out on his chance to fuck her. It was so amazing to feel her sucking his cock. He had missed the feeling of a nice warm mouth wrapped around his penis. It was especially nice that she was leaving his balls alone.

Lauren stopped sucking him off and stood on her knees. She looked down at Dave, his short penis standing fully erect. She had never had sex with a fat guy before, or a guy with a dick this small.

Dave marveled at the view of her breasts hovering over him as she climbed onto him. He let out a moan of ecstasy as he felt his cock slip inside of her warm, silky slit.

While he was shorter than she was used to, his girth filled Lauren right up in a satisfying way and she was able to get his cock all the way inside of her. She was surprised at how much she liked the feeling of it. Her tight vaginal muscles clamping down on his penis from all sides. All of the men she had been with before had larger dicks and they could only go so far in without feeling painful. She grinded down on him hard and could feel her swollen clit rubbing into his pubic bone, it felt great.

Dave couldn't believe this was happening. This woman was so hot. Her pussy was so tight and wet. It was better than he could have dreamed. He wished this moment could last forever but he also knew he was really close to cumming. He wanted to make it last so he was going to try to prevent himself from cumming as long as possible but it was going to be a challenge.

Lauren was enjoying the feeling of bouncing her clit off of Dave's crotch. She had no idea that sex could feel this good. She was so turned on right now. He might not be good at fingering or eating pussy but he really was an amazing fuck even if he was just laying there. She never liked penetration but this was the best sex she'd ever had.

Dave watched in amazement as this beautiful woman rode his cock with the most enthusiasm any woman had ever fucked him with. Her tits bounced up and down as she fucked him and it was hypnotic to watch.

Lauren bucked her hips violently as she rode his dick. Something shifted in the motion and as she came back down she could feel her ass bouncing up and down on Dave's testicles. She kept going and decided she would only stop if Dave stopped her. She was so close to cumming. She squeezed his cock tightly in her pussy and continued to grind down on his dick and balls.

Dave felt the shift and could feel Lauren's ass bouncing up and down on his sore, swollen balls. He stiffened a bit at the sensation but to his surprise, it didn't hurt as much as he would have expected. It reminded him of the previous hand job Lauren had given him, where she squashed his nuts between her hands as she jerked him off. It hurt, but it kind of felt good, and the thought of that devastatingly amazing ass bouncing around on his balls while she fucked him so hard was such a turn on. It was like she couldn't get enough of his cock and needed as much of it inside her has she could get.

Lauren started to cum hard, she couldn't believe how amazing it felt. She moaned loudly and continued to ride Dave's cock. Dave moaned in succession as her big ass thumped down on his balls. She couldn't tell if he was moaning in pain or pleasure. As her orgasm finished she sat with his cock fully inside her, her ass squashing his balls as she grinded back and forth pressing her clit down as hard as she could as she tried to squeeze out every last moment of pleasure from their encounter. She loved the feeling of sitting on Dave's swollen nuts with his cock trapped inside of her while he moaned. She hoped he wasn't in too much pain, but if he was he probably would have stopped her. She imagined what it would feel like to be in Dave's position, with a woman sitting on his nuts and squeezing the life out of his penis with her vice-like pussy.

Dave felt Lauren's orgasm begin and it pushed him over the edge. Her hungry pussy was squeezing his dick so hard and the rhythmic slapping of her buttcheeks on his testicles made his dick pulse as he spewed semen inside of her delightful cunt. His orgasm came to an end as she came to a stop on top of him, crushing his balls. He moaned and after a few moments he tapped her side.

She leaned forward, lifting her weight off his balls and asked "Are you finished honey?"

He grabbed onto her ass and nodded, hoping she wouldn't sit back down on his balls again.

https://www.reddit.com/r/BallbustingStories/comments/1flmzsv/strange_sympathy_chapter_12_what_happened_at/