Halloween Mask Party- Shocking Reveal

I arrived at the party late. A friend had told me about. It was an “Frat Masquerade”. Only rules were you had to wear a mask that covered your whole face.
Since I had arrived to college I hadn’t been able to get any girls, I was hoping this would be my lucky chance
I made my way in and to the booze, most of the guys had on cheesy horror masks. I had on a V for Vendetta mask I bought for 1.99 at rite aid 6 years ago
Most of the girls wore masquerade style masks, but they all were wearing next to nothing. Tonight could be my chance

For a few hours I went up to random groups and talked, a lot of them said they liked my mask, it stood out from most of the basic Jason, Michael Meyers, and clown masks. Eventually a group of 3 took me upstairs where we joined a group of 7.

“Hey, V. You ever play spin the bottle with a bunch of drunk sluts?” A Jason mask asked me
“Um- no I haven’t, Jason”
“Sluts, really Caleb?” A girl in a cat mask yelled out, slapping the guy in the nuts. Everyone laughed, while my hairs stood on edge. The way she just casually de-powered him, and he didn’t even resist or argue back. She took notice of my look through my mask and I could see the grin under her mask

Spin the bottle, my first game. The paired couples went down the hall into one of three room. After 2 others, it was my turn. I spun the bottle as fast as I could, it spun around and landed right at the cat mask girl.
“Well well, I get the new kid on the block. Cmon V.”She took my hand and lead me into one of the room.
I went in and she closed the door behind me….
My heart beat was pounding and I was sweating. Holy shit, was I about to finally get laid
“H-hey what do we do kn-“
My heart beat was stopped by a wave of pain
“Ohhh fuck….”
The catgirl had walked up behind me and moved her hand around my waste. I looked down and her hand condensed tightly around my bulge, her thumb expertly pressing my nuts into her palm
“Shhh quiet… okay listen V… normally our rules are you show me a good time, I show you a good time. But I play a little different”
As she keeps her grip on my nuts she slowly spins around me coming in front of me
“But I play a little different…” she brings her other hand forward
Both hands clamped down around my balls and I feel a pain I hadn’t known possible. The only time I’d felt this pain was when I pissed my sister off and she kicked me in the nuts.
“P-please stop! You’re crushing my nuts”
“No shit!!! You seriously think you can just come in here and have your way with us girls?”
She twists each wrist the opposite way and I let out a squeal before she moves her hand away
“Oh. Oh thank god…”
*THWACK*
A perfectly placed kick. I was lifted off my feet by this girl who was a foot shorter than me. I was completely winded and my hands went to my knees as I fought to avoid falling to the ground
“Oh my god… you just-“
*THUM THUM THUM THUM*
She just as quickly moved forward, grabbing my shoulders and launching a series of marching knees
I stood there with a open mouth like a fish out of water before falling to my knees
“Hmph cmon even if you got lucky and got someone else to rape you wouldn’t be able to keep up with that stamina…”
“I wasn’t gonna rape anyone! I just wanted to meet someone I swear”
She crouched down and while I kneeled down she placed her palm calmly on the underside of my balls
“I literally got you by the balls V, don’t lie to me”
“I swear, I’m a virgin I just wanted to meet a hot girl”
“Hmm I’d believe you but um…” she moves her hand forward “why’re you hard V?”
“Wait that’s not what you-“
She kicked me by my hip, flipping me so I was on my back. Grabbing my ankles and pulling them to her side, she started planting her foot down on my balls like a gas pedal
“I call this the wheel barrel!”
I rocked my head back as she stomped my balls back into my pelvis, but her foot was also pressing down onto something else
I could do nothing as she so easily de-powered me. Staring at her helplessly as I waited for our 10 minute timer to end so I could escape this nightmare, I noticed she had taken her cat mask off… HOLY SHIT
“Wait wait wait…. SARA STOP ITS ME”
“W-what? Who he fuck are you”
I removed my mask and her faced completely dropped from demonic satisfaction to a look of true horror. Happy Halloween…


I remember my asshole friend had joked about it when I told him I was going to this anonymous party, but I never expected to actually run into my sister

_____________________________________________
Inspired by request from u/ballbustboy