Flatmates - Ch13: Mia or Lexi?

Twenty minutes later, Jake sat on his bed, horny and confused. He had no idea what was happening outside his door. The whispers and occasional shouting from the living room had his imagination running wild. When the door finally swung open, his jaw dropped. Mia and Lexi stood in the doorway, both dressed in skimpy lingerie, their eyes smoldering as they stared at him. He could feel the tension between them as they walked inside. 






"Alright, Jake," Mia said, her voice dripping with anger. "We've had a long chat and it seems like you're getting the best of both worlds. We're going to play a little game to help you figure out who you really want to be with."



Lexi stepped forward, her eyes flashing with a mix of anger and desire. "Yeah, because apparently you can't keep your hands to yourself or your dick in your pants," she snapped.



Jake's eyes darted between the two of them, his heart racing. "What are you talking about?" he stammered.



Mia smirked. "We talked about it, Jake, and it's pretty obvious. You came into my room today because you wanted me to see you naked, you wanted me to catch you - You were hoping that I would be amazed by your big cock. Lexi doesn't want to accept that you clearly fancy me, so we're going to make you choose," she said, her voice low. "And we're going to make sure you really think about who you want to be with."



Lexi nodded in agreement. "You're going to have to make a hard decision tonight, Jake. The only way you're getting out of that cage permanently is by choosing one of us," she said, her voice filled with venom. "after all our time together, I can't believe you've been getting off on trying to expose yourself to Mia. If you chose me after all of this, I might keep that cock locked up permanently until we meet up. 



Fear flashed in Jake's eyes, imagining his life of chastity. He stared at Mia, shocked that she'd managed to manipulate the situation to her advantage. 



In her head, Mia was laughing. This was going exactly as she wanted. Lexi had no idea of what Jake and her had been up to, but now she could play with him right in front of her. It was just so exhilarating.



 "Take off all your clothes and follow us. NOW" Mia ordered. Knowing that the chastity cage would not be coming off until he'd obeyed their every command, Jake immediately stripped off and ran out to the living room.






Mia and Lexi had set up a makeshift stage with cushions and a spotlight. They stood in front of him, arms crossed, looking like two furious goddesses. "You've been a bad boy, Jake," Mia said, her voice a mix of anger and amusement. "And now, you're going to have to work for your release."



"We're going to have three challenges," Lexi announced. "The girl who wins two or more gets to keep your chastity keys."



"But don't worry," Mia added with a wicked smile, "the loser gets a parting gift of thirty minutes with you, all to herself, to do whatever she wants."



The thought of being at the mercy of either of them sent a thrill through Jake's body, despite his fear. "What are the challenges?" he asked, his voice shaking slightly.



"The first challenge is an edging marathon," Mia began, her eyes glinting with excitement. "You will sit here and we will take turns teasing you, bringing you to the edge and then stopping, 30 seconds each. When you beg the person teasing you to stop, that person wins."



"But remember," Lexi interrupted, her gaze cold, "the overall loser gets to torture... I mean play with you at the very end, so be really careful who you choose."



Jake nodded, his cock already straining in the cage as it reacted to their words.  



Actually Jake, we want you to lie between the table and the sofa, so that we can tie you up. Spreadeagle, just how you probably like it, huh? You big pervert. I can't believe I still want your cock inside of me after all this drama." Lexi raged, grabbing him by the balls and pulling him down. "oh and don't you dare cum, or we'll kick you in the balls so hard that they'll be turned to mush" she threatened. 



"Oh come on Lexi, if he cums, that's on us. I thought you were an expect cocktease, or were you lying all to me all this time?" Mia questioned, her eyebrows raised. 



"oh shut up Mia, I was just trying to scare him. Of course he won't be cumming, unless we decide to let him. Now grab the cuffs and lock him down, so that we can remove the cage and get to work" Lexi ordered.





Mia smirked, her eyes sparkling with mischief. She retrieved the velvet-covered cuffs from her dresser and helped Lexi tie Jake down, his limbs spread wide open. The metal cage was cold and unforgiving against his skin, a stark contrast to the warmth that had been building within him.



With a dramatic flourish, Lexi held up the keys. "Ready to beg, Jake?" she asked, her voice dripping with sweetness that didn't quite reach her eyes.



Jake swallowed hard, his cock pulsing in anticipation. "Yes," he murmured, his voice tight. "But only if you two are nice to me." he joked.



The two girls exchanged a look and burst into laugher. Mia leaned over to whisper in his ear. "No wonder you've gotten away with so much Jake, you're so funny. We're going to be very nice, Jake. But remember, if you cum without permission, we're going to make sure you regret it," she whispered, her breath hot against his skin.



With that, they gently unlocked the cage, Jake's cock exploding out in anticipation of the edging marathon. Each took turns stroking and teasing his cock, their gentle touches bringing him closer and closer to the edge of climax. Jake bit his lip, his eyes squeezed shut as he focused on their every move. He could feel the heat of their bodies as they leaned over him, their breasts brushing against his chest.



Mia started, her hands feather-light as she stroked him. She knew exactly how to push him to the brink, her thumb circling his sensitive head while her other hand cupped his balls, gently squeezing them.



Lexi took her turn, her touch a little rougher, a little more demanding. She didn't bother hiding her anger, using her nails to scrape lightly along the shaft, sending shivers down his spine.



Jake's breathing grew ragged as the minutes ticked by, each stroke bringing him closer to the edge. He could feel the cage digging into his flesh, a constant reminder of his predicament.



Mia stepped back, watching him with a smug smile. "Your turn, Lexi," she said, licking her lips.



Lexi's hands took over, her movements slow and deliberate. She leaned down to whisper in his ear, her breath hot and moist. "Who do you want to win, Jake? Who do you want to control your cock?"



Jake's body was on fire, his hips bucking involuntarily. "I...I don't know," he managed to gasp out.



"Tell us," Mia demanded, her hand sliding down to stroke his thigh. "Tell us who you want to win."



"I...I want..." he began, his voice trailing off as Lexi's hand tightened around his shaft.



"Tell us," Lexi whispered, her teeth grazing his earlobe. "Tell us who you want to win, and maybe we'll let you cum."



Jake's eyes snapped open, meeting Mia's. "No! Please, just let me cum" he begged. "I don't want to choose!"




Mia's smile grew even wider. "Oh, but you must," she said sweetly, her hand sliding up to cup his balls. "Tell us who's the better cocktease, and maybe we'll show you some mercy."



Lexi's hand stilled, her eyes boring into his. "Choose," she said, her voice low and dangerous.



Jake's mind raced. He didn't want to upset either of them, but the pressure was unbearable. "Mia," he gasped out, his voice barely audible. "You're the better cocktease."



Mia's eyes lit up with victory, and she leaned down to kiss him deeply, her hand still cupping his balls. "Thank you, Jake," she murmured against his lips.



Lexi's expression was unreadable, but she didn't move away from him. Instead, she leaned down and took his cock into her mouth, sucking hard. Jake's hips jerked up, a strangled moan escaping his throat. He felt Mia's hand tighten around his balls, her nails digging in slightly.



The sensations were too much, and Jake felt himself start to cum. But just as he reached the peak, Mia squeezed his balls hard, cutting off his orgasm. He let out a strangled cry, his body convulsing with the effort to hold back.



"No," Mia chided, her voice playful. "You didn't get permission." She released him, and Lexi stood over him, her eyes gleaming.



"You chose Mia, huh? Really? I don't think you'll enjoy the second game as much, Jake. I really don't think you know what you've done..." Lexi sighed, her disappointed face slowly shifting to anger as she picked up the chastity cage.



"no, actually, let's leave his big cock unlocked, I want to see it twitch and leak everywhere" Mia interrupted. "Jake, we are going to bend you over the sofa and use some rope you stretch your arms out, ok?" she asked, as she released his restraints. 



Unable to control himself, Jake grabbed his cock and tried to cum, but Lexi was ahead of him. Her fist thumped into his balls, flattening them against the floor, causing him to scream. With only one limb untied, he struggled to curl up and protect his nuts.



"bad boy! We said no cumming. As punishment, you will be locked in chastity for the next week. Mia and I will continue to Game number 2 next week, once you've learnt to behave. As punishment, you will be our naked butler this evening, serving us as we watch tv together." she ordered, grabbing his hand and cuffing him again. 



As Jake's erection withered due to the immense pain, Lexi stood over him, even her incredible body not enough to counter the devastating pain in his balls. Moaning in agony, he watched her grab the cage and snap it around his cock, sealing his fate for 7 days. Horrified by his mistake, he begged the girls for release.





"Please, Mia, please, Lexi, I can't take this," he whimpered, his voice cracking. "I'll do anything, I'm so sorry."



Mia's smile was like a cat playing with a mouse. "Oh, you're sorry now? That's so cute," she said, patting his cheek. "But sorry isn't good enough. You have to serve us, like the little slut you are."



Lexi leaned down, her breath hot on his ear. "You're going to be our bitch for the next week, Jake. And if you're a good boy, maybe we'll let you cum when we're done with you. Stop arguing or we'll give your balls something to think about"



The thought of being denied relief for so long was agonizing, but the earlier hammer fist to his balls immediately made his decision for him. He nodded, tears of pain in his eyes. "Okay, okay, I'll do it," he murmured.



Mia and Lexi released his cuffs, and Jake gingerly got to his feet, his balls still throbbing from the hit. He looked at them, hope in his eyes. "Can I...can I have my keys back now?"



Mia laughed, a sound that was music to his ears and yet filled him with dread. "Not a chance," she said, plucking the keys from Lexi's hand. "These are ours now. And look, we've got a little necklace for them," she added, holding up a delicate chain with a keyring attached.



With a flick of her wrist, she looped the necklace around her neck, the keys resting between her breasts, a constant reminder of his fate. "But don't worry," she said, her voice soothing despite the situation, "you'll be getting plenty of attention."



Lexi stepped closer, her eyes gleaming with something darker than amusement. "We're going to enjoy watching you squirm, Jake," she said, her voice low and seductive. "But first, you're going to serve us."



Jake's face fell. "What do you mean, serve you?" he asked, his voice shaking.



Mia gestured to the TV. "You're going to get us snacks, refill our drinks, and do anything else we say," she said, her tone firm. "And you're going to do it with a smile on your face. After all, this is your punishment for not being able to control yourself."



The thought of being their servant, denied his own pleasure, was almost too much to bear. But the pain in his balls was a stark reminder of their power over him. "Okay," he murmured, his eyes cast down.



Mia stepped closer, her hand reaching out to cup his cheek. "Look at us, Jake," she said gently. "Look at the two girls you want so badly. The two girls who are now in complete control of your cock and balls."



Jake's eyes snapped up to meet hers, and then to Lexi's. They both wore expressions of amusement and excitement, their eyes glittering with mischief.



Lexi nodded. "Good boy," she said, her voice a purr. "Now go get us some snacks. We're going to need them for the next few hours."



Jake slunk away, his naked body feeling more vulnerable than ever as he walked into the kitchen. The TV blared in the background, the sounds of the reality show filling the room. His mind raced with thoughts of what the week would be like, his body already craving relief.



As he returned with a tray of snacks, the girls were already settled on the couch, their legs entwined, watching the show. They didn't even acknowledge him as he set the tray down, his balls swaying slightly with every step.



"Thanks, Jake," Mia said absently, her eyes on the screen. "You can sit here," she added, patting the floor in front of the couch. "get on all fours so that we can rest our feet"




Jake nodded, his cock still sensitive from the edging marathon and the painful punishment. He knelt on the floor, his head bowed, and placed the tray down before moving to the spot she indicated. Lexi's eyes followed his every movement, a wicked smile playing on her lips.

 



With a heavy sigh, Jake settled into position, his hands and knees on the cool hardwood. Mia and Lexi swung their legs over the edge of the couch, placing their bare feet on his back. The weight of their legs, one on each side, was surprisingly comforting, a reminder of their dominance over him.



Mia wiggled her toes, her foot pressing down slightly, and Jake felt a strange mix of submission and arousal. "Comfortable?" she asked sweetly, her eyes never leaving the TV.



"Yes," he murmured, his voice thick with need.



Lexi leaned back, her foot moving to his ass, giving it a gentle tap. "Good boy," she said, her voice laced with sarcasm. "Now, let's see how long you can stay in this position without asking for a break."



The minutes passed as they watched TV, their snacks long finished. The only sounds in the room were the mundane sounds of the show and the occasional sigh or giggle from the girls. Jake's knees began to ache, his cock straining against the cage, but he didn't dare complain.



Mia, noticing his discomfort, decided to add a twist to the game. "You know what, Jake?" she said, her voice light. "We're going to make this a bit more interesting." She grabbed a bottle of lotion from the coffee table and handed it to Lexi. "Lexi, why don't you give him a foot massage?"



Lexi's smile grew even wider as she took the bottle. She pumped a generous amount into her hand and began to rub it into her foot. "You know what's going to happen if you cum, right?" she asked, her voice a warning.



Jake nodded, his breathing shallow. "Yes," he whispered.



Lexi began to rub her foot against his caged cock, her movements slow and deliberate. The slickness of the lotion made it glide over his sensitive skin, sending waves of pleasure through him. He bit his lip, trying to focus on the pain in his knees rather than the building pleasure.



Mia's foot joined in, the softness of her arch pressing down on his balls. "Relax, Jake," she cooed. "We're just giving you a little extra attention."



The sensation of their feet moving in unison against him was almost too much to bear. He could feel the cage digging into his skin, a constant reminder of his inability to find relief.



"You're doing so well," Mia said, her voice filled with fake encouragement. "Too bad you can't cum."




Jake's eyes watered as he felt Lexi's toes pressing harder against his cage, the lotion making the plastic glide over his skin. "I can't take it," he moaned.



Without warning, Lexi ripped her thong off and shoved it into his mouth. "Shh, don't be so noisy," she whispered, her eyes gleaming with mischief. "We don't want to ruin the ambiance."



The girls then proceeded to ignore him completely, their legs moving rhythmically over his body. They talked and laughed, occasionally sipping on their drinks as if he weren't there, his body serving as nothing more than a footrest. The humiliation and frustration grew with each passing moment, his cock straining against the unforgiving plastic.



Mia's foot traced lazy circles around his cage, her toes occasionally brushing against his balls, sending jolts of pleasure and pain through him. Lexi's foot remained on his back, pressing down slightly, keeping him in place. The TV played on, the reality show's contestants oblivious to the erotic torment unfolding in front of it.



The ache in Jake's knees was a dull throb now, his mind a whirl of desperate need and painful denial. He tried to focus on the pain, the way it grounded him, but the feel of their feet on his body was too distracting.



Their conversation grew more and more explicit, the girls discussing past conquests and sexual escapades with a casualness that made his blood boil. He could feel his cock pulsing against the cage, desperately seeking release that wasn't coming.



As the night wore on, their giggles grew louder, their touches more deliberate. Mia's toes began to tickle the sensitive skin of his inner thighs, making him squirm. "You like that, don't you?" she teased, her voice sweet and cruel.



Jake could only mumble through the gag, his eyes pleading for relief. Lexi leaned over, her hand sliding down to adjust the cage, the cold metal sending a jolt through him. "You're going to be our little toy for the whole week," she said, her voice a purr. "And we're going to enjoy every second of it."



Their feet moved in tandem, sliding over his body, teasing him, tormenting him. The pressure was unbearable, but he knew better than to protest. He had chosen this path, and now he had to follow it to the end.



As the hours ticked by, Jake's desperation grew. He had never been denied for so long before, and the thought of another six days like this was maddening. His body was a taut bowstring, ready to snap at any moment.



Their game grew more intense, their feet moving faster, pressing harder. Jake felt his orgasm building, the pressure in his balls almost unbearable.



But just as he thought he couldn't take anymore, the TV show ended. "Looks like our little Jake is going to cum without permission," she said, her voice mocking. "That's against the rules, isn't it?"



Lexi nodded, her eyes gleaming with excitement. "We can't have that," she said, her foot pressing down on his cage, the pain cutting through his pleasure. "You're going to have to learn to be a good boy, Jake."



Their laughter filled the room as he moaned into the gag, his body writhing beneath their touch. 



Lexi leaned in, her eyes gleaming with excitement. "I need to head off now, but don't worry, Jake," she whispered, her breath hot against his ear. "I'll be taking the keys with me. We'll need your balls full and recovered for next week, so look after yourself."



Mia nodded in agreement, her smile wicked. "Remember, no cheating," she said, her foot sliding off Jake's back. "It's not like he has a choice."



With a flirty wave, Lexi stood and put on her clothes, leaving her thong in his mouth. She made her way to the door, her hips swaying with each step. Jake watched her go, his body a live wire of need. As she reached the door, she turned back to him. "Come on, crawl over here and say goodbye properly," she ordered, pointing at her feet.



Jake hesitated for a moment, his pride bruised and fear of anyone walking past the hallway, but the pain in his balls was a stark reminder of his new position. With a sigh, he pushed himself off the floor, the cage digging into his sensitive skin with each movement. He made his way over to her, his eyes on the floor.



As he reached her, Lexi extended one foot, her toes pointing. "Kiss them," she instructed, her voice cold.



Jake leaned in, his breathing heavy, and placed a chaste kiss on the arch of her foot. "Thank you, Mistress," he murmured, his voice muffled by the gag.



Lexi rolled her eyes, but she couldn't hide the smirk that played on her lips. "So eager," she said, her foot nudging his face. "You're going to be a lot of fun."



With one final look, she turned and left, the door clicking shut behind her. Jake remained on the floor, his heart racing with a mix of fear and arousal. He watched as Mia stood and stretched, the yoga pants she's slipped into clinging to her body like a second skin.



"Don't worry, I'll take good care of you," she said, her voice deceptively gentle. "Now, go clean up the mess you made on the floor."



Jake looked down and realized he had indeed made a mess. The cage had rubbed against his skin, leaving a smear of precum and sweat on the hardwood. He groaned, his cheeks flushing with embarrassment.



Mia's laughter was like a knife, cutting through his humiliation. "Don't be shy," she said, her voice filled with amusement. "You're going to have to get used to this."



With a final look of defeat, Jake turned and began to clean up the floor, his ass in the ear and his balls swinging. The week ahead was going to be long, and he knew it was going to be filled with more edging, more pain, and more moments like this, serving Mia and Lexi's every whim.



But as he worked, his thoughts drifted to the promise of next week's game. The anticipation of what they had in store for him was almost as intense as the pain in his balls. And deep down, he knew he was going to beg for it.