Her Brother’s secret - pt 4

Apologies for the short gap between posts, your comments and upvotes always encourage me to write more so do let me know if you like it.

——————————————————

Part 3 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ChastityStories/s/B4Xma0geb9

——————————————————

Tony didn’t reply to Lucy’s message until Sunday night, partially because he was annoyed at her taking his situation lightly again and also so she didn’t have any reason to discuss his caged situation with Brad whilst they hung out over the weekend.

Both nights were increasingly uncomfortable as Tony grew more horny each day. The fact Lucy had now seen his junk multiple times when 10 days ago he’d have given anything for that to be the case seemed surreal. Susie meanwhile, had suggested several times that they go for another date, and whilst he wasn’t really against the idea, if he still had this cage on then it would be a ridiculous move on his part to agree. That said he was sure she’d lose interest if he kept being vague with her. Hoping beyond hope that by next weekend they would have found the key he agreed to meet up next Saturday. Maybe he could blow a two-week load all over her tits…he thought. Since being caged Tony had started spending significantly more time imaging how he would blow his load. Lucy’s face, Susie’s tits, there were a few repeat options that kept surfacing until his cage strained painfully and his balls ached.

For any of them to become a reality he needed to get the tiny black cage off his dick. Swallowing his pride he dropped Lucy a text.

9:21pm: “Hey, hope your weekend with Brad was good? Shall I come to yours after school tomorrow?”

9:48pm: “Tomorrow might be a bit tight, come on Wednesday, I can have a good look through Dylan’s stuff whilst he’s at basketball. What’s two more days?”

9:50pm: “two more makes 12…so my balls will be full to the max by then 🫠”

9:51pm: “Great, can’t wait to see the color they are by then”

Tony fumed for a while before responding, Lucy was enjoying this almost a little too much. Each time he typed out a long paragraph trying to get her to take it seriously he got cold feet, when he reread them he just sounded so pathetic. It had only been just over a week, she was going to find the right key soon now Dylan was back, really it was just really unlucky timing that meant he was still in the cage.

10:08pm: “Yeh they’re pretty sore and full, so we have to get the key from Dylan on Wednesday, I can even ask him for it outright.”

He knew this would irritate her but he didn’t care, he needed to get out of the cage and his tolerance for politeness was wearing thin.

———————————————

Monday and Tuesday were once again punctuated by cage straining and awkward locker room changing. The smallest hint of something horny made his dick ache and pulse in the cage. Having never pre-cum a huge amount before, suddenly he was leaking like a tap. True to Lucy’s wishes his balls were becoming redder and fuller every day.

Wednesday meant tolerating Brad’s constant droning on about his sex filled weekend and snide comments about “Tiny Tony”. Each time he said this he’d look straight at Tony, goading him for a reaction. Tony managed to keep a lid on his anger by telling himself the cage was coming off tonight. Without a backwards glance at Brad’s smug face he headed off to Lucy’s after school.

“Hey nerd” she greeted him at her front door 20minutes later, giving him a quick hug she led him up to her room. It felt weirdly personal being in her bedroom with the usual girly vibe of an 18yr old teen’s bedroom. Most of the time they hung out in the lounge for movie nights, somehow this felt more intimate. Lucy wasted no time.

“Can I see these big aching balls then?” She asked, again fumbling with his trousers already. Tony was taken aback and a little love bombed, it felt strange for her to be so desperate to get into his pants when he’d just spent the last 2hrs being riled up by her boyfriend. A small part of him felt like she was cheating on Brad with her lustful desire to see his junk. Still, he hesitated.

“I don’t know Luce, I’ll let you do the honours when we find the key later but there’s nothing to be gained from you seeing them now…it’ll only get me more frustrated” he hadn’t meant to be so truthful with the last sentence, it had just kind of slipped out.

“Awww baby, I just want to see what another 5 days has done to them, you promised they’d be full to bursting” Lucy was pulling out some more of the stops now, pouting slightly, somehow her arms were pushing her breasts together and she continued to tug on his waistband. Tony wanted to resist, yes it had been his fantasy for a long time for Lucy to want him this badly, but not whilst he couldn’t capitalise on the situation. Lucy, however, knew what she was doing; slowly she lowered herself onto her knees, replicating the “about to give a blowjob” porn position. The mere sight of her face so close to his crotch drove the horny virgin beyond the point of reasonable restraint, almost automatically, he moved to drop his pants and boxers. Within seconds Lucy was keenly fondling his swollen nuts and brutally locked cock.

“Oh my god they are so RED” she squealed with excitement, without warning she reached out and licked one of his balls, from the end up to where the cage sealed his dick in. Tony felt goosebumps rise all over his body, Lucy was wild and absolutely fearless in putting his junk in her mouth, why the fuck was this happening now when his dick was off the cards?! Tony knew his cock would start leaking pre-cum in buckets if she kept up this level of attention to his manhood.

“I want to see how it compares to last weekend” Lucy pulled out her phone to get up the last pic she’d snapped of his junk unsolicited. Tony was relieved to see that it did at least reside in her “Hidden” album, alongside what he recognised as Brad’s horse cock and a few interesting pictures of her, which he would have very much appreciated a longer look at.

“Hmmm they’re deep red, and SO fat”, with her left hand Lucy pulled his balls down into her palm, squishing them gently together and tugging so they pushed up all around the cage. With a few quick swipes she had her camera app open and had snapped another picture of his precious caged cock.

“Whaaa, Lucy did you just take another pic?” Tony asked, knowing full well she had.

“Hehe whoops, I just want to see how full they can get like, you make it sound like a big deal and they do look pretty stuffed” she replied, dropping his balls and moving away from him.

Tony couldn’t shake the feeling she’d got what she wanted out of him, and that was another compromising picture of his privates.

“Uhh, yeah but you can see that rn, you don’t need to take a pic of it?” He felt his irritation at Lucy rising again, being caged had shortened his temper somewhat, usually he was a very chilled guy.

“Of course I can, but I promised I’d show Susie an update on how you were holding up”

“WHAT” Tony shouted before remembering where he was, suddenly he was acutely aware that Lucy’s parents were likely at home. He hurriedly pulled his jeans back up and recovered some of his composure, “you’ve told Susie about this?” He hissed. Lucy laughed.

“Oops, of course I have, she knows a lot about chastity you know? Yeah she was some dudes key holder for a while earlier this term. They’d met on Reddit or something and he’d posted her the key, she played around with him for a bit, drove him crazy being a brat and then decided he was faking the whole thing. She flushed the key and forgot about him, two weeks later she got all these photos of him in the ER and the cage being removed by bolt cutters! It was fucking hilarious” Lucy was doing her typical innocent girl act, babbling away seemingly oblivious to Tony’s disinterest in the minor details and growing irritation at the bottom line; Lucy didn’t seem to think this was something to keep secret.

Lucy carried on chatting, taking the opportunity to bury a few more facts she knew would push his buttons. “Obviously when I mentioned I knew a virgin who’d got himself locked and we didn’t even know if the key still existed…well she was desperate to see your fat manly sack! Still, she says 12days is nothing and most guys don’t turn into mindless gooners until at least a month…so we’ve got ages to find the key” Lucy looked up from her phone and beamed at Tony. Tony stared back, the panic had overtake him, as if Lucy had told the girl she’d set him up with that not only was he a virgin, but he was caged!?

“You told Susie I was a virgin??” He stammered, of all the waffle this was his burning question, the rest could wait.

“Oh, yeah I guess I did. I didn’t mean to tell her it was you, but it just kinda came out, she put two and two together, sorry about that. Really though, she seems super keen to be your keyholder, she didn’t judge you at all for being in a cage” Lucy looked him dead in the eye, “I think you’d enjoy having her a key holder, she’s strict though”

“Me-I-what-no” Tony spluttered, this was too much all in one go, just minutes before Lucy was practically sucking his cock and now this, he felt like his stomach had dropped down a floor. “I don’t want a key holder! I don’t want to be in a cage!”

“Aww I know hun, but if you look down…you like…are in one. And you put it on for me right? So I feel like somewhere in there you must have wanted someone to hold the key?”

“I put it on because you bet it would fit!” He countered.

“Oh come on Tony, you’re telling me you wouldn’t enjoy it if I was your key holder?” Lucy was turning it on again, moving closer to him, holding eye contact and slowing down her words. “You’re saying, just hypothetically, if I knew exactly where the key to this little cage was right now you wouldn’t find it hot that you’d need to satisfy me to get out?” She put such an emphasis on the word ‘satisfy’ coupled with a little poke of her tongue out that left no doubt what she meant. Tony flushed, he could start denying it, but maybe now was the perfect opportunity to hint at his true feelings, it seemed like Lucy already knew.

“I…well, like, for you, I guess, I’d want to get that key yeah. You don’t know exactly where it is do you?” He asked hopefully.

“Hahah no silly, that was just a bit of role play, if I did have it here on a necklace I bet you’d do some naughty shit to get hold of it” she replied, now so close to his face that he could smell her perfume. He was sure she could hear his heart pounding. “How about on Friday we properly role play me being your keyholder?” She practically whispered in his ear.

Tony swallowed hard. “Friday? Aren’t we looking for the key tonight?”

“Hmm, I don’t think so, I think you like the fantasy idea that I hold your key. I think you deserve to reach a full two weeks in that tiny cage, and I think you’re going to thank me right now for ever locking you in it.”

Tony barely missed a beat “thank you” he whispered. The second he said it he knew he’d fucked up.

“Oh my fucking god I was just playing with you Nerd! Hahahaha” Lucy exploded with laughter, punching his arm, “you were really into that just then!” Tony felt the intense cringe embarrassment grip him, he flushed hot red and wanted nothing more than to disappear from this moment.

“Ahh yeah just kidding” he tried meekly.

“Susie was so right, boys brain’s really do go to mush after their cocks go in cages, that is WILD” Lucy was smirking at him knowingly. “Let’s see if we can find this key then loser, can’t have you literally drooling over me every movie night”.

“Don’t tell Susie about I that” Tony blurted out, unable to stop himself.

“Awww I won’t, I promise. But I will have to show her the pic, or she’ll never stop harassing me for it.” Lucy left no room for negotiation on this point, she was at the door and thew it open before he could respond.