Her Brother’s secret - pt 6

Final part for this week, expect a few more next weekend!

Part 5 available here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ChastityStories/s/AOgBkaoLkN

——————————————————

Tony was dumbstruck. He felt anger rise up inside him at the same time as embarrassment and blind panic. He needed to get the cage off right now, he began tugging at his cum soaked cage but quickly stopped as it painfully compressed his now comically large, swollen balls.

“Awww baby don’t freak out, if you look on the bright side this will totally help your chances with Susie” Lucy’s attempt to consoled him only caused him to spiral further.

“I don’t want to do this Lucy-“ he started.

“Oh Tony” Lucy cut across him, “this is your best chance to get laid!” Lucy sounded a little exasperated, as if she’d already explained something several times and he still wasn’t getting it. “Let’s be honest you didn’t stand much of a chance to lose your virginity any time soon, I saw this chance to help you out and I took it. I know you’ll be fucked off with me to start with but honestly I am doing this to help you. And after what Brad told me about…” Lucy trailed off, suddenly embarrassed herself.

“About what? What did Brad say?” Tony’s mind was spinning, none of it added up, why was Lucy talking as if this had been some grand plan she’d put in place for his own good.

“Oh, nothing really” Lucy deferred, but Tony wasn’t giving up that easily, after several more “what?”s and long pauses from Lucy she finally spat out, “well he mentioned you didn’t have a huge package…and you’re pretty chilled so, we thought having Susie as a keyholder would be perfect for you!”

This was the final straw for Tony, seething that Lucy had listened to Brad’s lies to cooked up this elaborate plot, pushed him over the edge. He grabbed the towel and started roughly wiping the cum off his cage and tender balls. “I’m getting out of this cage right now” he said quietly, standing up he crossed the room. “I don’t care how embarrassing it is for you, I’m going to ask Dylan where the key to this stupid cage is and I’m cancelling my date with psycho Susie tomorrow too.”

“Umm Tony” Lucy said quietly from the bed, “maybe I wasn’t entirely honest with you” Tony hovered in the doorway, he was ready to stop listening and storm out the door to wait for Dylan to return home, it couldn’t be long now until they’d be back, but something in Lucy’s tone made him pause.

“If I’m honest, I don’t quite have ‘no idea’ where the key is…like I don’t know exactly where it is” she added quickly, seeing his eyes bulge nearly out of his head. “I found it in Dylan’s wallet last night you see”

Relief flooded Tony’s body, he felt his shoulders drop several inches, every muscle in his body had been on edge and tense without him hardly recently. Breathing deeply he felt the panic subside, there was a key, he could get the cage off.

“Great” he almost smiled, the relief was so strong, “so where is it?” Lucy was looking bashful sat on the bed, avoiding his eye.

“You’ve still got the key right?” Tony asked.

“Okay promise you won’t be mad” Lucy started, but it was too late Tony had started connecting the dots, everything she’d said just now about how this was his big chance to lose his virginity and how she was trying to get him laid. He knew the answer before she even said it, his stomach dropped and the color drained from his face.

“I dropped it off at Susie’s this morning. She will be a GREAT key holder dude, she really will, she’s done it for loads of guys and shes so excited for it” Lucy smiled up at him. “Boys are so short term in their thinking, but really this is the best thing for you, so much better than gooning over me in the friendzone for the next few years”

Downstairs they heard the door open, her parents and brother were back. Tony quickly put his trousers back on as Lucy’s mom shouted up to them about leaving the TV on.

“I better head home” Tony said, he could barely look at Lucy, how could she have set him up like this? She’d found the key and then given it away to a girl he’d been on one date with. He didn’t care for a second about her stupid rationale that it was all for him in the long term, he’d have lost his virginity at college in a few months anyway.

Tony decided to walk home, his mashed up manhood rather tender with each step but he wanted some time to think. Walking home his anger with Lucy only grew, how dare she claim to know what was right for him, how dare she listen to Brad trash talk his dick size, the dude had only seen it in the locker-rooms, what did he know. After having the cum beaten out of his balls his mind felt strangely clear, whilst not satisfied he definitely felt less horny and far less likely to fall for Lucy’s pouting and flirting. All that mattered now was talking to Susie on their date tomorrow and getting the key, he could explain it had all been a big misunderstanding, he wasn’t into chastity at all and he’d take the key back.

——————————————————

Saturday came and Tony’s dick followed its usual ritual of straining hard against the metal cage, it had been a pain to clean the dried cum out as best he could. His balls at least hurt a whole lot less than the night before.

Tony got to the cafe early and bagged a table, he was nervous. Their first date had been pretty stilted, now he was in a cage and she knew the most intimate details of the worst experiences of his life so far so…it could only get more awkward he guessed.

Susie was blonde and fairly attractive, tits not quite as full as Lucy’s but she did have a tiny waist and a very perky ass. She arrived a little late, ordered a coffee and the small talk started flowing. Tony had been steeling himself to ask about the key straight away, but it was just too awkward, he’d fumbled and now they were chatting about summer holidays and favourite bands. Conversation was much easier this time, maybe Susie was more relaxed or into him now, but everything just seemed to work. When they finished their drinks they headed for a walk around the park, coming to bench they sat down and conversation lulled; Tony saw his opportunity.

“Susie, I don’t know what Lucy has told you, but I think there’s been a misunderstanding” his voice was shaking a little as he spoke, “I only put that cage on for a few minutes as a bet and like, I’m not into chastity at all, so I don’t know if you brought the key with you but like, I’d kind of like it back to get this cage off”

Susie stared at him, the silence stretching between them, for a moment he feared that Lucy had been lying to him all along and hadn’t shared anything with Susie. Then finally she spoke, “hmm, no I don’t think so, you see, that’s not going to work for me. If a little beta virgin is silly enough to get his dick locked in a cage then I think he must have known, at least subconsciously, that he belonged there, don’t you?” Her brutal response surprised him, just minutes before they’d been happily chatting about dog breads and now this.

“Err, the thing is Susie, I’m not into all that-“

“It doesn’t really matter if you’re into it” she cut across him, “once you’re caged it only matters what your key holder wants. Lucky for you, I’ve broken many betas in, I’ve never done it with a virgin though. This will be extra fun” she finishes the sentence with an evil grin and reached out to hold Tony’s aghast face in her hands.

“Please” without thinking Tony began to beg, “please I don’t want this, I just want to be let out this cage, whatever Lucy has said I’m not into it” tears were starting to gather in his eyes.

Susie rolled her eyes, “aww I was warned the virgins cry a lot. Fine, if you’re going to be a whiny bitch about it all the time I’ll give you one chance to get out the cage. Come over to my place tonight, my parents aren’t home, and big your best sub energy, ok?”