All is fair || Part 2

Content warning : >!imagined castration!<, >!rupture!<

Done and done! Still, there's much to improve for later works. A pleasant reading to you!

[Previous](https://new.reddit.com/r/BallbustingStories/comments/odnjsn/all_is_fair_part_1/) [Next](https://new.reddit.com/r/BallbustingStories/comments/oi4h9i/all_is_fair_part_3_final/)

\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_

After spending the night in relative peace, waking up only five times to check if your balls were still there after the sudden pains and to make sure no hostile Sophias were lurking around, ready to strike your manhood at any moment, you struggled to enjoy your breakfast despite it being prepared practically right before your eyes and with no interference from your rival.

“*She could’ve easily gotten something in there while I blinked*” even though you knew how unlikely that was, just the thought of having to go through all that again was more than enough to keep you on the edge. Sure, you knew how to hasten your recovery, but without a strong aphrodisiac or someone’s helping hand, you doubt you’d be able to get hard, let alone successfully orgasm with all that nutpain

Surprisingly enough, the morning was uneventful with only your paranoia getting the best of you, but then again, in just a few minutes you’d either get to continue living a normal life with your past transgressions forgiven, or run away in shame and never look back and after everything Sophia made you go through, you were starting to doubt your chances.

On your way to the notice board, a familiar disturbance echoed in your mind, “You better hurry”, she said “or can you not run with your sore balls?” just from her tone you could feel how delightfully happy she was. It was almost as if you played right into her hands.

“It’s over...” you thought and propped yourself up to a wall.

“Oh don’t say tha\~t! Come on, move! Or do you admit defeat and I can just go ahead and tell everyone? You know, if the kind and merciful me did all that to your poor nuts, imagine how much the others would like to have a go at them when they learn of your misdeeds.” as if her tongue was a rapier, she skillfully struck where you were weak. You couldn’t even guess why she’d want to come and see the results, except if she enjoyed seeing you suffer and her victory was assured.

“Did you hear that Carmilla practiced marshal arts for five years? Someone once locked her in a bathroom stall as a bad joke, she punched the door so hard the poor prankster got impaled by the broken bits, haven’t seen them since...” despite really not wanting to, your mind helped you imagine exactly how it would feel to have her fist connect with your ballsack and turn the insides into a bloody pulp if not just blow it right off. Trying to at least distract yourself from delving further into it, you thought to yourself “*That explains the abs.*”, this time making sure to not let Sophia hear that and use it to fuel Carmilla’s rage any further.

You guessed that the darned devil of a woman won’t stop listing off people you’ve jerked off to until you arrive, and you were completely correct, “Anne, on the other hand, recently picked up an exoctic hobby, could you guess what it is?” you knew it was pointless to think about it, but as you thought about the dark-haired girl who was way too self-conscious about her body, which probably stemmed from the marks on her skin which you tried deciphering in-between fapping sessions, but failed to get any real progress. Not hearing an answer from you, Sophia decided to speak up, “You really don’t pay attention to the girls you wank to, do you? As expected from the Creepeye, you don’t even see us as people.” she seemed annoyed, angry, even. Yet, she continued in her usual teasing tone, “She’s been raising abyssals. Hungry little buggers, they are. Anne doesn’t know what she’s getting into, but while she can still control them, I think you understand how dangerous they can be,” abyssals, you’ve heard that word before, but it was something that was mentioned as mere fiction. You couldn’t even imagine how they looked like, but from the name alone and from how Sophia decided to describe them, you imagined hundreds of teeth sinking into your nutmeat and devouring your balls while they’re still attached to you. At that point you didn’t even notice how you started picking up pace, as even the thought of meeting such a grim end was too much for your feeble mind to handle.

“But that’s nothing compared to our cute little torture specialist,” as if on purpose she went on and continued as soon as you were managing to convince yourself that things will be fine, you didn’t want to hear it. You tried to shut her up, “Please, not Lia...” while you wanted to say something much more harsh, your weakness showed in your words as even without Sophia saying much you could already imagine how much pain Lia would put you through. While, without a moment of doubt, Sophia and the ones she mentioned before would be able to cause much more damage, Lia would be able to make you experience every single method they’d be able to use and then sprinkle some of her own on top with her superior illusion spells. You’ve been on the receiving end of her attack once and if not for her holding back, would probably lose your mind, and you’ve seen what happened when someone did get caught, the poor boy was bedridden for days from a single spell and also probably from her kicking him in the nuts while he was down and helpless just to leave a lasting impression.

“Oh\~, so you do your research, after all. Very well, then, how about… ah… you’re already here, no fun!” While she did transmit you that message, she was completely unfazed by your arrival as far as everyone standing near the notice board was concerned as her eyes never even turned to you as you approached and started scanning the many papers with everyone’s marks.

“*Hahaha\~! Yes! I did it! I won!*” a perfect mark in front of your name was for all to see and it certainly wasn’t a trick. Yet your happiness was short-lived as you glanced down and saw that Sophia also had a perfect mark.

“Attention, everyone, Marco here is… got you good, didn’t I?” Sophia’s voice rung in your head as she pretended to shout the message. “That said, you failed to score higher than me, so\~”

“You’re being unreasonable! There’s no way I could get more than perfect!” you finally snapped and started using the same telepathic link she used to torment you to talk back. “Do you have any idea how much you’ve hurt me already even before the marks were announced?! If you do that… if you do that, I’ll tell everyone you hexed and poisoned me, I’ve got proof!”

But to your babbling you received a long laugh. Sophia herself was as calm as she always has been, not even letting a single emotion of hers show while you had trouble standing from how much your heart was racing. Your life would be ruined and she was laughing, laughing and walking away from you as if you weren’t worth her time.

“As if anyone would believe you. And even if they did, do you think I would be reprimanded for punishing a good-for-nothing creep?” in your mind, she was probably right, but having it spelled out for you only hurt more, “That said, if you feel that I’m being unjust, come meet me in the cavern after lunch, we’ll settle things there.” she couldn’t hold her excitement while saying that as even her manner of walking changed a bit as she challenged you to what could only be a duel.

Between running away as far as your legs would allow and fighting her for a chance to redeem yourself, you chose the latter and soon enough were standing in front of the entrance of the cavern not too far away from the dorms. It wasn’t dangerous or anything, it was just too boring of a place for anyone to be in except for very specific circumstances such as the one you found yourself in.

Knowing that she was already there, waiting for your arrival, you took a deep breath and moved in. “*I’ve beaten her once, I’ll do it again. I know how she fights, I know her spells. As long as I’m not reckless, I’ll win!*” with nobody else to support you, you cheered yourself on by your lonesome. “*She only hurt me so much because she caught me off guard!*” as you thought that, you almost stepped on a rune. “*Hmph, didn’t even try to hide it.*” with a wave of your hand you dispelled her trap and the invisible one right after it. “*Does she think I’m some sort of… calm down. Relax. Don’t rush it...*”

Scouting ahead with your farsight, you took note of the, frankly speaking, way too many traps for one to think this wasn’t planned days in advance. Aside from those, you also found the culprit standing proudly in an open area. Dropping her pure act, she looked genuinely excited for what was about to happen. And from her movements you could assume that she was preparing her speech. “*I see. This must be an act. She probably already knows I’m here. Have to be careful.*”

The moment you stepped from behind the corner and rushed in, shooting out elemental spells in her direction Sophia took notice of you and answered in kind, visibly annoyed at you not planning to play by the book. Back and forth flew lighting and ice, winds strong enough to shred flesh and blaze hot enough to boil blood, neither of you planning on backing down even a single step, but, just as it was the first time around, in this specific type of duel, you had the edge over her. Sure, she’d win if you got caught in the traps she laid down, but since you already knew where each of them were, she could only hope that you’d make a mistake. “*Don’t rush, take your time. I can attack longer than she can defend...*”

In between the sparks and dust, you noticed something off about her appearance, her clothes, or what remained off them barely covered anything. The moment of confusion was all she needed to start pushing back.“What is it!? Haven’t seen a naked girl up close? As expected of a virgin!” and even though she said that, and even though she was actually gaining ground on you, you could tell from her tone that she was more than embarrassed by her strategy of choice. “*I’ll laugh when I win, for now, words mean nothing if they’re not part of a spell.*” Effective as making you gaze at her bouncing breasts was, remembering what your nuts went through thanks to her made you focus on what was on the line.

The exchange was taking too long and at this rate it was anyone’s game, but it seemed that Sophia had prepared another ace up her sleeve as she took a piece of fabric that somehow wasn’t damaged in the fight and threw it out. A burst of energy enveloped the arena whole, almost making you think you blacked out as both of you stopped casting spells, but you definitely were standing and didn’t feel anything wrong. In the brief moment of peace, you managed to take a good luck at the shameless woman who didn’t even mind getting naked if it meant getting an advantage. You had to admit, currently she was sexier than when you spied on her in the shower. It was either because she got naked specifically for you, or thanks to the heat of the battle, it mattered not as you tried to resume your onslaught, but nothing happened. Your spells definitely worked, but the moment they were released into the battlefield, the effects vanished as if you didn’t even do anything.

Sophia, on the other hand, had already closed the distance and was about to launch a full-force kick to your gonads. You didn’t even manage to cast a protective spell as you rushed to get out of the way of her strike.

**CCRUNCH!**

“MY BALLS!” you screamed out as her strike lifted you off the ground, painfully crushing your nuts between her foot and your pelvis before sending you flying backwards with a second kick right in your solar plexus. Lying on the ground you struggled to get some air as you couldn’t even continue screaming, only taking shallow breaths as the agony spread throughout your body, almost to the point of shutting you down. Her movements were fast, way too fast even. You could tell she was athletic even the first time you saw her taking a bath, but what she just pulled off could only be explained by arcane enhancement.

“*She crushed them… she really went ahead and crushed them… ah… no… two, both of them are there...*” lying in a fetal position you clutched at your swollen balls that were being mended by your spell, it was surprising that nothing broke from that strike as the pain suggested that she broke the nuts to pieces, but you could only be glad that she didn’t and fight on if you wished for your manhood to remain intact.

“‘My balls!’ hahahaha\~! I’ve never heard a guy scream in a pitch that high.” saying that mockingly, she walked up to you and forced you on your back before spreading your legs apart, sending in a shock just to paralyze you for the time being. You thought you had more time, but it seemed that she wasn’t going to let you recover. You didn’t want to watch, but you had to, you needed to see it happen if you wished to have a shot at victory.

“*So those spells work… perfect… ah… my balls… MY BALLS!*” Before going through with her plan, she decided that you needed some adjustment, and so she forced your pants off of you and grabbed you by your balls, for a moment her touch felt like pure bliss, but that quickly changed as she started stretching them down to the ground, but as time and time again they failed to remain there, she decided to raise the ground a bit instead, letting your nutsack rest on the rough rocks like on a pedestal. Even as you prepared to get out, you couldn’t help but let your tears stream down your cheeks. Holding them in took too much willpower, and you didn’t have the luxury of sparing any for vanity.

“Come on, don’t make that face, I’m doing this for your own good. You won’t have the need to spy on other girls if you don’t have any sexual urges,” ironically enough, as Sophia said that and raised her foot right above your battered nutsack, her own slit was so wet that the juices dripping down her thighs glistened under the soft ambient light. “*Wait,* ***other***\*?\*” “Now, take a deep breath, it’ll only take a moment.”

Her leg rocketed down on the pair of swollen testicles like a hammer attempting to flatten out a nail.

**CR-BOING! SPLURT**

“AAAAAAAAAAAARH!” you screamed your lungs out as the full force of her strike connected with your enchanted nutsack, which, thanks to your quick thinking, momentarily acted like a spring and sent her leg backwards, knocking her off-balance. Had you used the spell even a little too early or too late, the pain you were experiencing would’ve told you exactly how fucked your nuts would have been. Moreover, since your balls thought they had exploded, they made sure to send out a massive load in an attempt to impregnate at least something, but only managed to coat Sophia’s legs in it. Unfortunately, even though you managed to survive the attack, she wasn’t defeated yet, only more annoyed at the fact that you not only were still capable of fighting back, but also had the audacity to knock her off her feet.

The two of you hastily tried to stand back up, Sophia obviously having an easier time since she didn’t have to deal with two dangling orbs swinging around and causing excruciating pain just by existing after that strike.

“*Too hazy… can’t see...*” overwhelmed by what could only be the equivalent of having your balls popped twice over with no time to rest, you decided to go with an all-out assault before Sophia would have the chance to think of another way of permanently reducing your sperm count.

She was saying something, and she was angry, but you didn’t care enough to listen and rushed at her like a mad bull.

Even if you were physically weaker and even when your body was telling you to shut down in order to preserve itself, you pushed on, you only needed to touch her once in order to win, you only needed a single spell.

She tried to shoot something at you, but as her own nullifying field screwed her over, she was the one trying to escape.

With each step feeling like a sledgehammer was hitting you in the nuts, it was a miracle that you made it that far, but in your blind rage, you failed to notice her striking back instead of running away.

\*\*THUD-POP!\*\*Only your left ball got caught in-between her knee and your body, splitting open with no chance of survival. Both of you screamed so loud your throats hurt, but kept going well past that. You succeeded, you managed to connect with the “shared pain” and now, just like you, she too was struck with pain so intense that she had trouble moving, but unlike you, there was something different for her as her agonized screeches turned to moans of pleasure as she convulsed in an orgasm so strong she got some of her love juices on you.

“*The bitch… she gets off to thi… ah… arg...*” even trying to think was difficult as the burst testicle ‘begged’ you to do something. You didn’t even know if you could do something about it, but as your hand reached your broken ball, the pain intensified so much that even Sophia, who was shamelessly masturbating to your pain stopped dead in her tracks, doing her best to catch a single breath.

It didn’t become manageable even a little bit, but somehow she moved on to you, sending shivers down your spine. Your heart raced as the naked maniac was inches away from your precious package, you couldn’t even muster a single spell out, let alone fight back.

“Y-you win” her voice cracked as she said that in a very unconvincing way before focusing her attention to your cock which failed to go limp even for a moment after her failed attempt at execution. “Do you accept your reward?” she said in a manner very unbefitting of the situation, even moreso since she seemed to be talking to the raging boner and not its owner. Even then, in your mind, you deserved something for your trouble, and so a single nod was enough for her to go on. Straddling you like a damn sex toy, she looked you in the eyes as she bounced on your dick with no regard to your well-being as her gorgeous ass flattened your nutsack each time she descended.

“*Wha-why? What is wrong with you?!*” even if you thought that, you couldn’t deny that despite all the pain, you were currently having the most glorious fuck of your life as the very moments you felt the most pain were the same in which Sophia’s walls tightened around your dick, taking its shape as if her pussy was made for you.

“I-I’m about to cum!” and that was enough for her to stop completely. You could see on her face that she wanted to continue and even her tight cunt was constantly trying to get the seed out of you, but she didn’t move, at least not intentionally. In a moment, you felt her hand grab onto the broken ball, getting a girlish scream out of you as she moved it in her hand, as if admiring her handiwork. From how it looked, it could still be saved, but the more she moved it, the more of the contents spilled out into the nutsack.

“I’ve made my choice… from this point o-onward you’re mine. D-do you understand that?”

Obviously, you didn’t catch a single part of it and the fact that she was struggling to keep her orgasms in check was certainly of no help.

“Y-you’ll be mine, and I… I’ll be yours.”

Having someone propose to you while you were balls-deep in them after a fight in which you lost half your manhood was unexpected, to say the least, but since it seemed that everything was already decided for you and since you really wanted to get this over with so you could fix your balls, you forced out a smile. “I understand” “*Then again, it’s not like anyone else would like a good-for-nothing like me*”

And the very next moment she resumed her motions, ready to ride you all the way. And it wasn’t like she had to try that hard as the orgasm welled up inside of you with no way of stopping it. As you were about to erupt inside her, she decided to finish what she started and shut her palm around what remained of your lefty, forcing every single bit of it out into your nutsack, leaving its brother to float in the mush right next to its empty shell. In that moment you felt the world collapse around you as her pleasured moans drowned out your weak screams right before you passed out.